Two security workers acquitted of using excessive force

superdrug

Two security guards who were accused of using unnecessary and excessive force while detaining a 15-year-old boy in a Superdrug store in Chichester have been cleared.

Jake De-Geus, 30, of Chichester, Sussex, and Edwin Hirst, 40, of Fareham, Hampshire, both denied charges at Portsmouth Crown Court.

The prosecution had claimed Mr De-Geus head-butted the teenager and both men used excessive force, including the use of handcuffs, on 22 March 2023.

Jurors cleared both men on both charges and Hirst was acquitted of assault against another teenager, on the direction of the judge.

The court also heard how a video of the incident was posted on social media by the complainant’s mother with accusations of racism.

However, the teenager, who is black, said he was “pretty sure” he had not told his mother that the defendants had been “racist” towards him.

The two defendants, who work for Chichester Business Improvement District, told the court they decided to stay close to the complainant and two friends because they were acting suspiciously.

After the teenager placed a bottle of shampoo into the pocket of one of his friends, Mr De-Geus said he had asked him to leave the shop, but said the boy became “angry and aggressive”.

Mr Hirst said he saw the teenager headbutt his colleague at which point he stepped in to assist and detained the boy using handcuffs until police arrived.

He said restraining him was done with “reasonable force” and in a “controlled manner”.

The complainant said he had only “jokingly” placed the shampoo in his friend’s pocket and said Mr De-Geus then “squared up to him” and became “really angry” before “he threw me into one of the aisles”.

The jury heard that the teenager had been also banned from Greggs in the town for stealing some potato wedges and had also been banned from the city’s Sports Direct shop.

What SIF offer

SIF members across the UK benefit from our expert legal advice, support and continued protection every day.

Services

  • Expert Legal Advice

    Provided by our dedicated support team and partners.

  • Wellbeing Support & Counselling

    Professional advice for internal discipline issues

  • Employment Rights Advice

    Dedicated support regardinging all workplace matters.

  • 24/7 Phone Support

    Expert advice via telephone support and counselling.

Latest from the Security Industry

Articles

Member Testimonials

Reviews

    "I cannot describe how SIF have helped me during a tough time with my company. They managed my meetings with HR and managers professionally and knowledgeably. They were also available to attend the meeting with me on short notice and always responded to my messages for any recommendations I needed."

    "I recently had a TUPE case and was struggling to get the holiday pay I was owed. The union SIF stepped in and provided amazing support throughout the process. Thanks to their dedication and expertise, I received the holiday pay I was due. I am incredibly grateful for their help and highly recommend SIF to anyone in need of union assistance."

    "Wonderful union. The General Secretary Daniel represented me recently and I was happy with the outcome. Join the SIF, the security union fighting for the welfare of security staff."

    "I cannot describe how Daniel helped me during a tough time with my company. He managed my meeting with HR and managers professionally and knowledgeably. He also was available to attend the meeting with me on short notice and always responded to my messages for any recommendations!"

    "Amazing union that offers benefits you can actually use. After a traumatic time causing me to take some time off work for mental health reasons, I was able to access the 'in person counselling' they offer, something quite unique as usually companies only offer the 'over the phone' or 'virtual' types. This helped me so much that 4 months later, I am back on my feet and in a great place! Thank you SIF!!"

    "I've been a member since April 2025, with the way things were going I thought I needed someone to look after my employment issues and interests if any cropped up, long story short, an issue popped up with the renewing of my SIA licence which left me extremely concerned, I wrote to Daniel asking for help and advice, with 5 minutes I received a reply somewhat calming my nerves and that he had written to the SIA, within 48 hours my licence was renewed thanks to the SIF and Daniel Garnham , extremely pleased with my outcome. If you work in the industry trust me at some point your going to need help, I can now sleep easy"